By spinytim on October 25, 2010
NeuroLogica Blog » CCSVI – The Importance of Replication
Scientists and skeptics are familiar with this pattern – a preliminary study suggests a wildly new understanding of a scientific or medical question. The scientific community is cautiously skeptical but interested. The press proclaims a stunning breakthrough, and the public is briefly fascinated. If the new discovery concerns a medical treatment, the community of those affected become fixated on the potential new “cure”, and many start demanding treatment based solely on the preliminary evidence. But then the wheels of research begin to grind and, more often than not (because that is the nature of discovery) the new idea turns out to be wrong – it fails the critical step of replication.


Posted in MultipleSclerosis, ppms | Tagged #CCSVI #multiplesclerosis #skeptic |
By spinytim on October 23, 2010
Interview with… Debbie Purdy « ‘i interview interesting people’
‘i interview interesting people’
twitter.com/robandale – facebook.com/robdaleworks
Interview with… Debbie Purdy
with one comment
Debbie Purdy, who suffers from multiple sclerosis, is the face of Britain’s right-to-die campaign. She doesn’t want to die. She has ‘far too much to live for’. But when the time comes, and the pain is so unbearable that she cannot go on, she wants her husband to be by her side, holding her hand until the end; and she wants to know that he won’t be arrested.
Debbie Purdy’s legal battle then was all about clarifying the law so she knew whether or not the authorities would prosecute her husband Omar if he helped take her to the Dignitas clinic in Switzerland to die. As the majority of comments left on my facebook note were highly pro-assisted suicide, I thought this interview would best serve the public interest if it opened up the story behind Debbie’s legal battle and allowed for a deeper understanding of why her and Omar believe so passionately that assisted suicide should be legalised in the UK
The first aim of the interview was to identify what multiple sclerosis (MS) actually means and its effects on the human body. So my initial question was quite simply, 15 years on from being diagnosed with MS, what is Debbie’s physical state?
Debbie said that really she is just the same as anyone else, everyone has problems, it’s just that 15 years of this MS means she is now in a wheelchair.
Debbie has primary progressive MS – she explained that this means that your central nervous system is like the wiring in your house. If the plastic protection on the wires becomes broken, the flow of electricity to certain areas stops. And that is exactly what is happening with Debbie – the current that flows from her brain to her muscles instructing them what to do is simply getting lost somewhere along the way.

Posted in MultipleSclerosis, ppms | Tagged #multiplesclerosis, #ppms #multiplesclerosisms, http://spinytim.com/, multiple sclerosis, ppms, primary progressive Multiple Sclerosis, Timothy Scratchit |
By spinytim on October 23, 2010
Posted in MS poisons my dreams |
By spinytim on October 22, 2010
Rolling around naked in broken glass.
Posted in MS poisons my dreams |
By spinytim on October 20, 2010
#ppms #multiplesclerosis ms, Multiple Sclerosis, #multiplesclerosis, #ppms, Timothy Scratchit, http://spinytim.com/, primary progressive Multiple Sclerosis,

Posted in MS poisons my dreams |
By spinytim on October 18, 2010

from flickr
I got hit with galloping ppms late last year, and so I’m still kind of in shock, having gone from zero to 6.5 on the disability scale in just a few months. But I can sincerely say that for the first time in my life I am fully living up to my potential, in that everything I do from petting my dog to composing this reply takes 100% of my attention. Anything less results in injury or failure. I would say that ppms is a high price to pay for the ability to be fully present in this moment, but it is something. And although I am in a highly precarious position and have never been as vulnerable and helpless and hopeless as I now find myself, I am too involved in surviving this moment to do much worrying about anything. I wonder if this is what being very very old is like?
Posted in MultipleSclerosis, ppms | Tagged #multiplesclerosis, MS poisons my dreams, ppms, primary progressive Multiple Sclerosis, Timothy Scratchit |
By spinytim on October 17, 2010
meds for primary progressive? | healthboard
Hi All,
I am brand new to this board, being diagnosed only yesterday. My neuro says he thinks I have primary progressive MS. He says there are no treatments/meds for this type. Is this really true? I would appreciate any input you might be willing to offer. Thanks!
Answer:
Answer:I’m sorry to hear of your diagnosis. Unfortunately I think your doctor is right. There are no treatments currently approved for PPMS. There is one approved for Secondary Progressive which is called Novantrone. I take that drug. It is a chemo therapy drug. Not sure if it would be helpful to you or not. I’m hopeful that better treatments for all types of MS are not too far off. By not too far, I mean within 5 years.
One caution I will give you. Having a chronic illness with no cure or treatment, makes many people susceptible to charlatans and frauds selling “alternative” treatments and cures that are not proven to be either safe or effective. I encourage you to be very skeptical of any such products.

Posted in MultipleSclerosis, ppms | Tagged primary progressive Multiple Sclerosis |
By spinytim on October 16, 2010
I am learning to write with speech recognition, so please forgive any irregularities.
It is difficult for me to write about my condition, because to commit to paper, so to speak, is to make it real. And even now, I am loath to make it real.
Every morning I wake diminished, and I think to myself: if I don’t get any worse than this, then I will be able to go on. I will be able to relieve myself, put some food in my stomach, take care of the dog and the cat, and go be productive for someone. Every morning I wake to find that my hands are more useless, curled, and insensate, add that my legs are more distant meat objects, useful as stilts, perhaps, but not much else.
And every morning I wake with fewer words.
Posted in MultipleSclerosis, ppms | Tagged multiple sclerosis, ppms, primary progressive Multiple Sclerosis |
By spinytim on October 15, 2010
Posted in MS poisons my dreams |
By spinytim on October 15, 2010
Posted in MS poisons my dreams |
By spinytim on October 14, 2010
About 18 months ago I began to experience numbness and tingling in my hands. Since I had no other symptoms and since the sensation was very much like carpal tunnel syndrome, I did a little research and concluded that my problem was most likely cubital tunnel syndrome. By last fall I was having a little difficulty writing my bicycle. By last Christmas I was dragging 1 foot. By last spring I concluded that I had primary progressive multiple sclerosis or something very much like it.
Now I am about a 6.5 on the multiple sclerosis disability scale. I’ve never had a remission; I have never awoken better than when I went to sleep.
My hands haven’t worked for some time, so I am learning to use voice recognition software to write with. Please forgive any irregularities.
Posted in MultipleSclerosis, ppms | Tagged #multiplesclerosis, Demyelinating Diseases, multiple sclerosis, ppms, primary progressive Multiple Sclerosis, Timothy Scratchit |
By spinytim on October 13, 2010
One Health Blog – Q&A About Health! » What could be a trigger factor of multiple sclerosis?
Management of progressive MS
Treatment of progressive MS is more difficult than relapsing-remitting MS, and many patients do not respond to any therapy. A wide range of medications have been used to try to slow the progression of disease. Many therapies have been shown to have some effect on disease progression and resulting disability, but most therapies have significant side effects which limit their long-term use. Therefore they are often appropriate only for the most rapidly progressive cases. Azathioprine, cladribine, and ciclosporin have all shown small benefits, which in most cases are outweighed by side effects such as an increased cancer risk. Mitoxantrone, a chemotherapy drug, offers a significant reduction in progression to disability, but causes dose-dependant cardiac toxicity which limits its long-term use. Bone marrow transplant, plasmapheresis, and total lymphoid irradiation (exposure to high doses of radiation in order to kill parts of the immune system) have been studied and are currently reserved for the most dire cases. Cyclophosphamide and methotrexate are chemotherapy drugs which can slow the progression of MS, but which also have a number of side effects. Frequent courses of high-dose corticosteroids, often given weekly or monthly, are also commonly employed to good effect. Interferons show promise in secondary progressive MS, but more data is needed to support widespread use.

Dreaming of dreaming.
Posted in MultipleSclerosis, ppms | Tagged #multiplesclerosis, http://spinytim.com/, ms, multiple sclerosis, ppms, primary progressive Multiple Sclerosis, Timothy Scratchit |
By spinytim on October 13, 2010
In fact, I may start getting worried sometime soon.
Beginner’s Guide to MS: Disability and the Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS) Score – Multiple Sclerosis
Lisa Emrich
In August 1955, Dr. Kurtzke published the Disability Status Scale (DSS) which is used to evaluate a patient’s impairment due to MS on a 10-point scale. In 1983, Dr. Kurtzke published the Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS) which has the advantage of evaluating all major neurologic areas.
Although the EDSS lacks sensitivity to short-term changes in a patient’s status, it is used extensively in national and international trials to evaluate the effectiveness of therapy. It is heavily weighted toward ambulation assessment and fails to assess cognition, upper extremity function, and fatigue.
Fundamental to the EDSS is the Functional Systems (FS) Scale which evaluates seven areas of the central nervous system which control bodily functions (0 = normal function and 6 = unable to complete task). The FS scores are especially important in the less severe forms of disability where a patient may have same abnormal disability but is otherwise still ambulatory.
The Functional Systems (FS) include:
Visual
Brainstem (speech and swallowing)
Pyramidal (ability to walk)
Cerebellar (coordination)
Sensory (touch and pain)
Bowel and Bladder functions
Cerebral/Mental
Please note that the EDSS steps 1.0 to 4.5 below refer to patients who are fully ambulatory and the precise step number is defined by the Functional System Score. EDSS steps 5.0 to 9.5 are defined by the impairment to ambulation and usual equivalents in Functional Systems scores are provided.
Here is a summary of EDSS scores (source NMSS) -
* 0.0 – Normal neurological exam (all grade 0 in all Functional System (FS) scores).
* 1.0 – No disability, minimal signs in one FS (i.e., grade 1).
* 1.5 – No disability, minimal signs in more than one FS* (more than 1 FS grade 1).
* 2.0 – Minimal disability in one FS (one FS grade 2, others 0 or 1).
* 2.5 – Minimal disability in two FS (two FS grade 2, others 0 or 1).
* 3.0 – Moderate disability in one FS (one FS grade 3, others 0 or 1) or mild disability in three or four FS (three or four FS grade 2, others 0 or 1) though fully ambulatory.
* 3.5 – Fully ambulatory but with moderate disability in one FS (one grade 3) and one or two FS grade 2; or two FS grade 3 (others 0 or 1) or five grade 2 (others 0 or 1).
* 4.0 – Fully ambulatory without aid, self-sufficient, up and about some 12 hours a day despite relatively severe disability consisting of one FS grade 4 (others 0 or 1), or combination of lesser grades exceeding limits of previous steps; able to walk without aid or rest some 500 meters.
* 4.5 – Fully ambulatory without aid, up and about much of the day, able to work a full day, may otherwise have some limitation of full activity or require minimal assistance; characterized by relatively severe disability usually consisting of one FS grade 4 (others or 1) or combinations of lesser grades exceeding limits of previous steps; able to walk without aid or rest some 300 meters.
* 5.0 – Ambulatory without aid or rest for about 200 meters; disability severe enough to impair full daily activities (e.g., to work a full day without special provisions); (Usual FS equivalents are one grade 5 alone, others 0 or 1; or combinations of lesser grades usually exceeding specifications for step 4.0).
* 5.5 – Ambulatory without aid for about 100 meters; disability severe enough to preclude full daily activities; (Usual FS equivalents are one grade 5 alone, others 0 or 1; or combination of lesser grades usually exceeding those for step 4.0).
* 6.0 – Intermittent or unilateral constant assistance (cane, crutch, brace) required to walk about 100 meters with or without resting; (Usual FS equivalents are combinations with more than two FS grade 3+).
* 6.5 – Constant bilateral assistance (canes, crutches, braces) required to walk about 20 meters without resting; (Usual FS equivalents are combinations with more than two FS grade 3+).
* 7.0 – Unable to walk beyond approximately 5 meters even with aid, essentially restricted to wheelchair; wheels self in standard wheelchair and transfers alone; up and about in wheelchair some 12 hours a day; (Usual FS equivalents are combinations with more than one FS grade 4+; very rarely pyramidal grade 5 alone).
* 7.5 – Unable to take more than a few steps; restricted to wheelchair; may need aid in transfer; wheels self but cannot carry on in standard wheelchair a full day; May require motorized wheelchair; (Usual FS equivalents are combinations with more than one FS grade 4+).
* 8.0 – Essentially restricted to bed or chair or perambulated in wheelchair, but may be out of bed itself much of the day; retains many self-care functions; generally has effective use of arms; (Usual FS equivalents are combinations, generally grade 4+ in several systems).
* 8.5 – Essentially restricted to bed much of day; has some effective use of arm(s); retains some self-care functions; (Usual FS equivalents are combinations, generally 4+ in several systems).
* 9.0 – Helpless bed patient; can communicate and eat; (Usual FS equivalents are combinations, mostly grade 4+).
* 9.5 – Totally helpless bed patient; unable to communicate effectively or eat/swallow; (Usual FS equivalents are combinations, almost all grade 4+).
* 10.0 – Death due to MS.

Related articles by Zemanta:
Posted in MultipleSclerosis, ppms |
By spinytim on October 11, 2010
It feels like a tight elastic girdle made of giant ace bandages, right down to the delusion of sweaty abrasion, from nipple level to pelvis. The pressure is weird, but bearable, but the illusory abrasion feels like my whole torso is being sanded with rock salt, and yet there is a numb Novocaine layer of flesh beneath it.
But, then, my hands feel the same, plus extra numbness to the bone, which distracts me from “the ms hug.”
Oh,& I take a buttload of Baclofen I get mail-order from India, but I am going broke, and as a broke USA citizen, I am anticipating some bad withdrawals. Which kind of sucks, considering Baclofen has no fun side effects at all.
Posted in MS poisons my dreams, MultipleSclerosis, ppms | Tagged #multiplesclerosis, Baclofen, India, MS Multiple Sclerosis, multiple sclerosis, ppms, primary progressive Multiple Sclerosis, spasticity, Timothy Scratchit |
By spinytim on October 11, 2010
Regional gray matter atrophy in early primary prog… [Arch Neurol. 2006] – PubMed result
BACKGROUND: Gray matter (GM) atrophy has been reported in multiple sclerosis (MS). However, little is known about its regional distribution.
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the regional distribution of GM atrophy in clinically early primary progressive MS (PPMS).
DESIGN AND PATIENTS: Thirty-one patients with PPMS within 5 years of symptom onset (mean age, 43.2 years; median Expanded Disability Status Scale score, 4.5) and 15 healthy control subjects (mean age, 43.7 years) were studied. All subjects underwent a 3-dimensional inversion-recovery fast spoiled gradient-recalled echo sequence that was repeated after 1 year in patients only. Magnetic resonance images underwent an optimized voxel-based morphometric analysis that segments magnetic resonance data volumes in a normalized space and quantifies tissue atrophy on a voxel-by-voxel basis. A lesion mask was created for each patient and used in normalization and segmentation steps to minimize bias from lesions. A multisubject design was used in the cross-sectional study to compare patients with PPMS and controls. A 1-way analysis of variance (within-subjects) design was used in the longitudinal study.

RESULTS: At baseline, patients with PPMS displayed bilateral thalamic atrophy compared with controls. In addition, a significant association between lesion load and decreased GM volume was found for the thalami. Loss of GM in the putamen, caudate, thalami, and cortical and infratentorial areas was observed in patients after 1 year of follow-up.
CONCLUSIONS: Atrophy is most obvious in deep GM in clinically early PPMS. This may reflect increased sensitivity of these regions to neurodegeneration. Cortical and infratentorial atrophy developed as the disease evolved.
[Caption]
Posted in MS poisons my dreams, MultipleSclerosis, ppms | Tagged #multiplesclerosis, http://spinytim.com/, ms, multiple sclerosis, ppms, primary progressive Multiple Sclerosis, Timothy Scratchit |
By spinytim on October 10, 2010
AskPhilosophers.org
Emotion, Ethics
If a person fails to feel pain or suffering for events which usually bring such things about – if they don’t miss their family or home while away, or if they don’t grieve for dead relatives or pets, or if they don’t get upset when they fail an exam or lose their job – is it sensible to hold them somehow for flawed, or to claim that they are inhuman? Is emotional numbness or indifference a moral wrong?

October 7, 2010
Response from Charles Taliaferro on October 10, 2010
Great question! You have definitely (in my view) described a disturbing emotional indifference or numbness, but this may not be due to any moral wrong. People might be in such a condition because they have suffered some great trauma or brain injury through no fault of their own. Philosophers have differed in terms of their view of how natural it is for us to empathetic or have sympathy for one another –Aristotle and Locke think we are desposed to care for one another whereas Hobbes almost sees friendship as something we are drawn to for reasons of prudence and self-concern (caring for others is a kind of strategy for us to avoid premature violent death). In natural law theory, lack of concern for the dead or an indifference to personal failure or failing to honor family may be seen as failures to exercise important human virtues (whether or not this is due to a vice or an innocent injury). But some philosophers in ancient Greece taught that we should try to give up desires and attachments –not all Stoics did, but some saw this as an important goal. Even so, the person you are describing may not so much be in the grip of a philosophical theory, as much as they are suffering from a disorder that has an organic or chemical base.

Posted in MS poisons my dreams, MultipleSclerosis, ppms | Tagged #multiplesclerosis, ms, multiple sclerosis, ppms, primary progressive Multiple Sclerosis, Timothy Scratchit |
By spinytim on October 10, 2010
Economic Issues Reach Multiple Sclerosis Patients – Multiple Sclerosis
It was the time of the cave man, the late 1970′s. There were no credit swaps or derivatives. People and not bankrupt banks actually owned homes. You see back then, when confronting a problem involving MS, all we had was a steroid and a dream. There were no interferons and copolymer (Copaxone’s forerunner) was unproven. Neurologists earning modest livings would go to the MS patient’s bedside and labor through time consuming examinations, unsupervised by HMO clerks limiting such profligate activity.
Many would pine for a definitive test for MS. But even CT scanning was in its infancy. The closest thing to an MRI (truly a milestone in MS evaluation) was its NMR (Nuclear Magnetic Resonance) predecessor- an organic chemistry test confined to lab experiments and not involving brain imaging.
MS patients actually got diagnosed on clinical grounds, perhaps with some help from cerebrospinal fluid oligoclonal bands and evoked response testing. ACTH and steroids helped some acute attacks. (Like now). Therapy for chronic progressive disease was as it is now- less than satisfactory.
Over these thirty years, scientific advances in imaging and therapy have outpaced our abilities to consistently utilize them to dramatically impact upon the lives of MS patients. (Key word is dramatically). Expensive MS research as Science Project Winner? First Prize. Expensive MS research to greatly reverse or cure MS? No prize. Yes we have cut into the number of relapses of MS patients with relapsing and remitting disease. Yes, we now have heavy hitters that can help a few patients with progressive disease. And yes, we are exploding research initiatives at an unprecedented rate.
I bring this up not to disparage the great advances we have made in the science of MS and even in helping particularly those with its common relapsing and remitting variant. I raise these points to highlight cost vs. outcome. If MS were the yardstick for measuring whether advances in diagnosis and treatment in the last 30 years can be supported economically, it would highlight an economically crippled “health care” system.
Wait a minute; we happen to have an economically crippled “health care” system.
Now we have a nearly crippled general economic system.
You see back in the cheapo late 1970′s MS patients were falling face down in the streets because no one examined or treated them- NOT.
You see back in the late 1970′s there was limited MS research and imaging and no MS patients were getting fantastically improved or cured- LIKE NOW WHEN NO MS PATIENTS ARE GETTING FANTASTICALLY IMPROVED OR CURED DESPITE AN EXPLOSION OF MS IMAGING AND RESEARCH.
Read The Whole Story Here
Posted in MultipleSclerosis, ppms | Tagged #multiplesclerosis, http://spinytim.com/, ms, multiple sclerosis, ppms, primary progressive Multiple Sclerosis, Timothy Scratchit |
By spinytim on October 10, 2010
Depression, Suicide and Multiple Sclerosis – Multiple Sclerosis
Suicide and MS have had a long relationship. This is Suicide Prevention Week (Sept. 5-11), and Sept. 10 is Suicide Prevention Day.
Depression is experienced in 40 – 60 percent of the MS population. Although MS is not a fatal disease, severe depression accounts for 3 to 15 percent of MS deaths by suicide. These are not insignificant statistics. While I am not a doctor, psychiatrist, psychologist, or any kind of trained therapist, I am going to talk about MS an suicide today. There are so many options for MSers who feel the pain of depression as well as some other symptoms.
There are documented cases of assisted suicides associated with MS, although it doesn’t happen so frequently since disease-modifying drugs have come on the scene. People who have MS and have developed symptoms that make life unbearable consider their options, and some select suicide . Of course, what is unbearable is an individual measure. Even Dr. Jack Kevorkian said, “I don’t persuade to suicide.”
Depression, Suicide and Multiple Sclerosis – Multiple Sclerosis”>Read the whole story here.

[Caption]
Posted in MultipleSclerosis, ppms | Tagged #multiplesclerosis, MS Multiple Sclerosis, multiple sclerosis, ppms, primary progressive Multiple Sclerosis, Timothy Scratchit |
By spinytim on October 9, 2010

Richard Pryor passed away due to cardiac arrest in 2005, after a 17-year battle against multiple sclerosis. Often joking about his condition, he referred to multiple sclerosis (MS) as “More Shit”.
Did you know what Richard Pryor referred to Multiple Sclerosis as?
Posted in MS poisons my dreams, MultipleSclerosis |